Why a dying man's album hits differently
Bowie released Blackstar two days before he died. Its power comes from one fact: he was dying as he made it. No AI can stand in that place.
David Bowie released his album Blackstar two days before he died.
David Bowie released his album Blackstar two days before he died. It is not only a set of songs. It is a final statement. Its power comes from one fact the listener knows: he was dying as he made it.
No AI can stand in that place. It has no life to lose. It can make something polished, moving, even new. But it cannot make a final statement, because that needs someone speaking from inside the very thing they describe.
This points to what art really is. It is not only a message that a receiver decodes. It is also a relationship between two people who both know they are finite.
This is why people grieve when an artist dies. It is not mainly that the new work has stopped. It is that a real bond has been cut on one side.
Because art is a relationship between two finite people, and the bond is cut.
David Bowie released his album Blackstar two days before he died.
Its power comes from one fact the listener knows: he was dying as he made it.
It can make something polished, moving, even new.
When Robin Williams died, the mourning was not only for lost films. His humour had felt like a response to his own pain. That pain was real, because it was happening to a person, in a life, under the pressure of time.
Its power comes from one fact the listener knows: he was dying as he made it.
Because art is a relationship between two finite people, and the bond is cut on one side.
Bowie released Blackstar two days before he died. Its power comes from one fact: he was dying as he made it. No AI can stand in that place.
This is the short version. Read the full-length essay, “The Artist’s Body”.
This issue is part of Everybody's Smart, a newsletter on taste, judgment, AI, culture, cognition, and the future of professional work. New issues every 2 to 3 weeks, free on LinkedIn.
Subscribe →